Soapbox on regenerative braking
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 422
- Joined: Sat, 15 Dec 2007, 05:09
- Real Name: Ian Hooper
- Location: Australia
- MSN: sigmunky@hotmail.com
- Contact:
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Matt: Yes, for me the most attractive aspect of regen braking is reducing brake use. 2nd most attractive is just the technical elegance of energy recovery. 3rd is additional range. I would love to have regen on my next EV, but I still don't see any compelling solutions on the market.
The "wear and tear" of a charge cycle is *roughly* proportional to the depth of discharge, i.e a regen event might recharge the battery by 1%, and you can do that 100x for the same effect it would have on your battery's cycle life as one full depth charge/discharge. (The math really isn't that simple, but you get the idea)
Low RR tires, you'd definitely notice the difference on a racetrack but unlikely to on public roads. Prius come standard with pretty good LRR tires if I remember correctly, have a drive in one of those and see if you notice any compromised handling. The coefficient of friction is maybe 10% lower so only an issue if you're pushing the limits of traction. (The Tesla Roadster as tested on Top Gear was wearing LRR tires and managed to equal a Porsche 911 GT3 around their race track - so they're clearly not too bad around corners!)
The "wear and tear" of a charge cycle is *roughly* proportional to the depth of discharge, i.e a regen event might recharge the battery by 1%, and you can do that 100x for the same effect it would have on your battery's cycle life as one full depth charge/discharge. (The math really isn't that simple, but you get the idea)
Low RR tires, you'd definitely notice the difference on a racetrack but unlikely to on public roads. Prius come standard with pretty good LRR tires if I remember correctly, have a drive in one of those and see if you notice any compromised handling. The coefficient of friction is maybe 10% lower so only an issue if you're pushing the limits of traction. (The Tesla Roadster as tested on Top Gear was wearing LRR tires and managed to equal a Porsche 911 GT3 around their race track - so they're clearly not too bad around corners!)
Ian Hooper
--
"Never doubt that the work of a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world." - Margaret Mead
http://www.zeva.com.au
--
"Never doubt that the work of a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world." - Margaret Mead
http://www.zeva.com.au
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 683
- Joined: Wed, 04 Mar 2009, 17:15
- Real Name: James Kennedy
- Contact:
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Don't forget the fun factor! Especially if regen is set up on accelerator pedal lift-off, you get a wonderfully smooth and controllable transition from drive, to regen, and back to drive, as you push through a corner. It's great!
- acmotor
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3603
- Joined: Thu, 26 Apr 2007, 03:30
- Real Name: Tuarn
- Location: Perth,Australia
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Here here ! now you're talking.
Few people have experienced the no gears, real regen driving experience.
Even in the non handling of a Suzi, it is not hard to imagine the future of performance motoring.
I guess it will truely come together when hub motors when TCS,EBD,ESC etc are lines of code in the drive computer !!!
Few people have experienced the no gears, real regen driving experience.
Even in the non handling of a Suzi, it is not hard to imagine the future of performance motoring.
I guess it will truely come together when hub motors when TCS,EBD,ESC etc are lines of code in the drive computer !!!

iMiEV MY12 110,230km in pure Electric and loving it !
- acmotor
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3603
- Joined: Thu, 26 Apr 2007, 03:30
- Real Name: Tuarn
- Location: Perth,Australia
Soapbox on regenerative braking
zeva wrote:
The "wear and tear" of a charge cycle is *roughly* proportional to the depth of discharge, i.e a regen event might recharge the battery by 1%, and you can do that 100x for the same effect it would have on your battery's cycle life as one full depth charge/discharge. (The math really isn't that simple, but you get the idea)
I'm not certain that you could produce data to back that 'rough' thought.

e.g. most Li cells will provide maybe 1000 cycles at 100% DOD, 2000 at say 80% DOD, 3000 at say 70% DOD, 7000 cycles at say 50% DOD and if that is any indication then maybe 100,000 cycles or more at 1% DOD
So your reasoning doesn't seem to follow (your maths too simple ? the relationship is not linear)
Excessive charge rate (for the chemistry/construction) is the only wear and tear you are likely to experience.
Keep in mind the overall reduction in DOD by as little as even 1% by regen is actually far more likely to increase battery life if manufacturer's stats are to be followed.
Prius is a classic example of vast numbers of shallow cycles with regen, so much so that the battery packs now have 8 year warranty !
iMiEV MY12 110,230km in pure Electric and loving it !
- acmotor
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3603
- Joined: Thu, 26 Apr 2007, 03:30
- Real Name: Tuarn
- Location: Perth,Australia
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Last edited by acmotor on Sat, 02 Feb 2013, 10:21, edited 1 time in total.
iMiEV MY12 110,230km in pure Electric and loving it !
-
- Groupie
- Posts: 86
- Joined: Tue, 26 Jun 2012, 15:08
- Real Name: ron Berry
- Location: Nimbin
- Contact:
Soapbox on regenerative braking
To my mind AC or DC is less appealing than a big axial flux PMDC for the following reasons;
-mostly the weight savings
-overclockable to not need reduction in the drive train thus even more efficient and light
-much less back emf so high speed is good
-simpler
-smaller
-cheaper
-DIY capable, both controller and making the motor yourself
-REGEN (is that the thread we are on?) is easy and very efficient
-hub motor shaped
-air cored is advantageous re saturation etc.
Also I am building an 80% efficient hydraulic regen setup for my range extending trailer but it could easily be fitted to a DC series motor especially one with a shaft at the other end. Very simple and reliable, cheap, light and DIY capable. Leaves the controller side of things very simple and cheap. I will try and find the hydraulic drivetrain patent that inspired me, it made the car very efficient, works for heavy machinery very well and is much more efficient than direct diesel.
-mostly the weight savings
-overclockable to not need reduction in the drive train thus even more efficient and light
-much less back emf so high speed is good
-simpler
-smaller
-cheaper
-DIY capable, both controller and making the motor yourself
-REGEN (is that the thread we are on?) is easy and very efficient
-hub motor shaped
-air cored is advantageous re saturation etc.
Also I am building an 80% efficient hydraulic regen setup for my range extending trailer but it could easily be fitted to a DC series motor especially one with a shaft at the other end. Very simple and reliable, cheap, light and DIY capable. Leaves the controller side of things very simple and cheap. I will try and find the hydraulic drivetrain patent that inspired me, it made the car very efficient, works for heavy machinery very well and is much more efficient than direct diesel.
- BigMouse
- Senior Member
- Posts: 600
- Joined: Thu, 28 Oct 2010, 02:39
- Real Name: Vincent Tannahill
- Location: Silicon Valley
- Contact:
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Can you show an example of a car-capable axial flux PMDC motor that's cheaper than a comparable AC or DC?unheardofinstruments wrote: -cheaper
-
- Groupie
- Posts: 86
- Joined: Tue, 26 Jun 2012, 15:08
- Real Name: ron Berry
- Location: Nimbin
- Contact:
Soapbox on regenerative braking
It has been frustrating getting any answers to price inquiries but Agni at $3000 (800 freight) for two 95R motors which would be ok for a lightweight car are the best so far and they have prototyped and tested their soon to be released 300mm high torque version. Waiting to see.
http://www.gkn.com/driveline/our-soluti ... fault.aspx
and Yasa motors are teaming up with these guys
www.axcomotors.com/axial-flux_technology.html
they said;
Base YASA-750 Motor £7900 ea.
Sevcon Gen4 Size 8 Controller £3500 ea.
Delivery is usually circa 6 to 8 weeks Delivery price to be agreed in advance
YASA-400 motors will be available for general sale in February. The sale price will be circa £7000. CAD and dimensional data will be available in the next few weeks.
The YASA-250 will follow in mid 2013, this motor will be a 15kg 85kW peak, 250Nm peak motor, ideal for motorcycles or small city car traction units directly into a differential.
these are supposedly going to allow them to be made cheaper using unique magnetic materials and yokeless design, pretty cool but expensive at low production volume 3 years in.
www.enstroj.si/Electric-products/emrax-motors.html from slovenia are expensive 2490euro (in 2011) and made for gliders and HV but seem very good
These guys are in sydney, waiting for an answer;
www.evans-electric.com.au/
ultramotive.com make a great motor, expensive but very high torque density
apex motors, saminco, soloman tech, zytec, UQM, Williams (of F1 fame) and many others never answered.
Launchpoint technologies ones are probably the best I have seen but they only seem to supply the military.
A dude in San Fran called Carl said he will make me two that would power a car for $2500US each and has made a few just for himself.
PML Flightlink, Volvo, Aisin Aw Co Ltd., Sim-Drive, Tepsc, Protean Electric, e-Traction, TM4, Ziehl Abegg, mitsubishi and Siemens amongst many others are working on hub motors too using axial flux designs so I would suspect someone in china is also and when they get into mass production they should be cheaper as they are much simpler to make, small companies hand making them for the ones who can afford it makes them seem more expensive than they should be with 7.5kW solar challenge motors (using the best of current design, hallbach arrays, variable gap, composites...) charge $12000 and no I can't get one of the hallbach arrays they use or know where they come from....aaaargh.
I think I will have to make my own and Craig from Turquoise Energy in vancouver supplies a very reasonably priced kit but I plan something a bit different; direct drive/low speed but the right magnets are proving hard to find. I have Axel Borgs book on how but waiting to see how the Agni one goes first.
If you can get them to write back let me know, I would love to find out what the various systems cost.
http://www.gkn.com/driveline/our-soluti ... fault.aspx
and Yasa motors are teaming up with these guys
www.axcomotors.com/axial-flux_technology.html
they said;
Base YASA-750 Motor £7900 ea.
Sevcon Gen4 Size 8 Controller £3500 ea.
Delivery is usually circa 6 to 8 weeks Delivery price to be agreed in advance
YASA-400 motors will be available for general sale in February. The sale price will be circa £7000. CAD and dimensional data will be available in the next few weeks.
The YASA-250 will follow in mid 2013, this motor will be a 15kg 85kW peak, 250Nm peak motor, ideal for motorcycles or small city car traction units directly into a differential.
these are supposedly going to allow them to be made cheaper using unique magnetic materials and yokeless design, pretty cool but expensive at low production volume 3 years in.
www.enstroj.si/Electric-products/emrax-motors.html from slovenia are expensive 2490euro (in 2011) and made for gliders and HV but seem very good
These guys are in sydney, waiting for an answer;
www.evans-electric.com.au/
ultramotive.com make a great motor, expensive but very high torque density
apex motors, saminco, soloman tech, zytec, UQM, Williams (of F1 fame) and many others never answered.
Launchpoint technologies ones are probably the best I have seen but they only seem to supply the military.
A dude in San Fran called Carl said he will make me two that would power a car for $2500US each and has made a few just for himself.
PML Flightlink, Volvo, Aisin Aw Co Ltd., Sim-Drive, Tepsc, Protean Electric, e-Traction, TM4, Ziehl Abegg, mitsubishi and Siemens amongst many others are working on hub motors too using axial flux designs so I would suspect someone in china is also and when they get into mass production they should be cheaper as they are much simpler to make, small companies hand making them for the ones who can afford it makes them seem more expensive than they should be with 7.5kW solar challenge motors (using the best of current design, hallbach arrays, variable gap, composites...) charge $12000 and no I can't get one of the hallbach arrays they use or know where they come from....aaaargh.
I think I will have to make my own and Craig from Turquoise Energy in vancouver supplies a very reasonably priced kit but I plan something a bit different; direct drive/low speed but the right magnets are proving hard to find. I have Axel Borgs book on how but waiting to see how the Agni one goes first.
If you can get them to write back let me know, I would love to find out what the various systems cost.
-
- Groupie
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Wed, 13 Jun 2012, 04:25
- Real Name: Damian butcher
- Location: Canberra
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Ok I'm just curious.
I looked at the Agni motors and after much comparing I settled on the mars me913
Is there something wrong with the mars?
I looked at the Agni motors and after much comparing I settled on the mars me913
Is there something wrong with the mars?
-
- Groupie
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Wed, 13 Jun 2012, 04:25
- Real Name: Damian butcher
- Location: Canberra
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Also regen round a corner? U mean braking round a corner?
No that's cool if your into that...
However as those who brake before the corner and power on will wave as they pass you
if you don't spin out.
On a race track that is
Coz for those of us like me n zeva with brute power and no regen we will be too busy lapping the AC tail runners
Perhaps they could pass a law that all AC must be put in combi vans with peace symbols and fight the man stickers

Sorry couldn't help myself
No that's cool if your into that...
However as those who brake before the corner and power on will wave as they pass you

On a race track that is

Coz for those of us like me n zeva with brute power and no regen we will be too busy lapping the AC tail runners

Perhaps they could pass a law that all AC must be put in combi vans with peace symbols and fight the man stickers


Sorry couldn't help myself

- Johny
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3729
- Joined: Mon, 23 Jun 2008, 16:26
- Real Name: John Wright
- Location: Melbourne
- Contact:
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Then the AC powered guys with regen will wave as they overtake you while you'r in the pits changing brake pads.
Edit in, not ein
Edit in, not ein
Last edited by Johny on Mon, 04 Feb 2013, 03:59, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Groupie
- Posts: 86
- Joined: Tue, 26 Jun 2012, 15:08
- Real Name: ron Berry
- Location: Nimbin
- Contact:
Soapbox on regenerative braking
The Agni R series are reinforced so rev out to 6000 rpm instead of 4000 and 30kW over 22kW peak and all of their motors have the upgraded design Cedric planned for the E-tek/Mars/LMC motors (before he got shafted) providing higher torque per amp and a speed per volt making the gear reduction ratio smaller. The Mars is cheaper though. From india I was quoted 3000 including the 800 shipping for two which would be good for a 750kg car without a gearbox.
- BigMouse
- Senior Member
- Posts: 600
- Joined: Thu, 28 Oct 2010, 02:39
- Real Name: Vincent Tannahill
- Location: Silicon Valley
- Contact:
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Any PM motor is still so expensive, not to mention reliance on rare-earth materials with wildly fluctuating prices (controlled by China). A custom wound induction motor only has aluminium, copper, and steel in it. Mine cost $1800 brand new delivered, and wasn't made in China. With the right controller and batteries, it'll be easily capable of "overclocking" to 100+kW.
For me, induction beats any PM motor due to material availability and cost.
For me, induction beats any PM motor due to material availability and cost.
- jonescg
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3046
- Joined: Thu, 21 Jan 2010, 23:05
- Real Name: Chris Jones
- Location: Perth, WA.
Soapbox on regenerative braking
If making an affordable yet punchy EV is the goal, induction is the way to go. If you want performance and don't mind paying for it, then PMAC is the only option. PMDC still has brush arcing and armature heating issues, but for the price of a decent one an induction motor is an attractive alternative.
AEVA National Secretary, WA branch chair.
-
- Groupie
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Wed, 13 Jun 2012, 04:25
- Real Name: Damian butcher
- Location: Canberra
Soapbox on regenerative braking
That seems very high price for shipping on the mars unheardof...
My warp11s cost 600 a pice to ship from the states and they are 100kg.
Most of the mars motors I have found are all around the $700 mark per motor
My warp11s cost 600 a pice to ship from the states and they are 100kg.
Most of the mars motors I have found are all around the $700 mark per motor
- Richo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3737
- Joined: Mon, 16 Jun 2008, 00:19
- Real Name: Richard
- Location: Perth, WA
Soapbox on regenerative braking
You'll even get free regen when your PM ev is being towed.
Unlike induction which will free wheel.
Hub motors again
People are trying to reduce the hub weight not jam more into it.
Convientent maybe, practicle not really.
Unlike induction which will free wheel.
Hub motors again

People are trying to reduce the hub weight not jam more into it.
Convientent maybe, practicle not really.
So the short answer is NO but the long answer is YES.
Help prevent road rage - get outta my way!
Help prevent road rage - get outta my way!
-
- Groupie
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Wed, 13 Jun 2012, 04:25
- Real Name: Damian butcher
- Location: Canberra
Soapbox on regenerative braking
And on the regen issue... Considering the extra cost of AC why not put those dollars into a bigger battery pack and enjoy the power of DC 

- Johny
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3729
- Joined: Mon, 23 Jun 2008, 16:26
- Real Name: John Wright
- Location: Melbourne
- Contact:
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Because the car gets heavier and more difficult to get approved (and to stop).Canberra32 wrote: And on the regen issue... Considering the extra cost of AC why not put those dollars into a bigger battery pack and enjoy the power of DC![]()
-
- Groupie
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Wed, 13 Jun 2012, 04:25
- Real Name: Damian butcher
- Location: Canberra
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Only if its a conversion 
Currently the rolling chassis with batt pack sits at just over 700kg and gets pulled up by 350mm willwood brakes
There no pass issue here
The body shell will be no more than 100kg unless I lay it up like a tank lol.

Currently the rolling chassis with batt pack sits at just over 700kg and gets pulled up by 350mm willwood brakes

There no pass issue here

The body shell will be no more than 100kg unless I lay it up like a tank lol.
- Richo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3737
- Joined: Mon, 16 Jun 2008, 00:19
- Real Name: Richard
- Location: Perth, WA
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Yep DC would be a good cost saving.
But the downside is, in my opnion, no DC motors meet NCOP.
Get the gaffa out and seal up those brush vents please...
But the downside is, in my opnion, no DC motors meet NCOP.
Get the gaffa out and seal up those brush vents please...
So the short answer is NO but the long answer is YES.
Help prevent road rage - get outta my way!
Help prevent road rage - get outta my way!
-
- Groupie
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Wed, 13 Jun 2012, 04:25
- Real Name: Damian butcher
- Location: Canberra
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Splitting hairs richo 
You gotta see the up side of what I'm building
check my CNC body thread for the shell shape and drool bebeh 

You gotta see the up side of what I'm building


- Richo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3737
- Joined: Mon, 16 Jun 2008, 00:19
- Real Name: Richard
- Location: Perth, WA
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Yeah I know and I do.
I started drooling about the CNC before I saw any pics of the cars
I started drooling about the CNC before I saw any pics of the cars

So the short answer is NO but the long answer is YES.
Help prevent road rage - get outta my way!
Help prevent road rage - get outta my way!
-
- Groupie
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Wed, 13 Jun 2012, 04:25
- Real Name: Damian butcher
- Location: Canberra
Soapbox on regenerative braking
Machining up new parts ATM so I can increase the Z axis travel and add a pivoting head but its all not happening fast enough lol
-
- Groupie
- Posts: 86
- Joined: Tue, 26 Jun 2012, 15:08
- Real Name: ron Berry
- Location: Nimbin
- Contact:
Soapbox on regenerative braking
I am now considering moving my hydraulic regen from the range extending trailer to the front shaft on the motor in the car as I have nothing on it at present having crippled the power steering and made it manual and I will probably like it when I am doing short trips too, lots of hills around here so it will definitely come in handy. I wish I had bookmarked the link to a 150 dollar addon regen unit for series DC motors from somewhere in eastern europe as I can no longer find it. Seems that was a niche with some promise, I think it was switchmode IGBT based current control and field excitation to make it happen. It would add some extra braking power and charge rather than save takeoff amp sucking. No reason not to skin the cat both ways. Anyone found such a thing? I remember someone from Australia asking about importing it.
-
- Groupie
- Posts: 86
- Joined: Tue, 26 Jun 2012, 15:08
- Real Name: ron Berry
- Location: Nimbin
- Contact:
Soapbox on regenerative braking
This is something that I had thought of ages ago, well explained. I wonder if it could be as simple as driving 3 coils in a four coil motor and using one to charge.
http://www.davidicke.com/forum/showthread.php?t=159243
http://www.davidicke.com/forum/showthread.php?t=159243
Last edited by unheardofinstruments on Thu, 07 Feb 2013, 19:03, edited 1 time in total.